In my opinion, lipliners by Catrice are really good. They are creamy, the colors are good. These two were new at my local drugstore, so I bought them. The right one is the Aqua Ink Lipliner Ultra Long-Lasting in 020 Just Follow Your Rose. Look at the tip:
It’s a spongy-like tip. Unfortunately it was already colored, so I guess someone tried it out before me.
As you can see in the swatch, it kind of bleeds. Haven’t used it on my lips yet, don’t think I will, because it was already used, but wanted to show it.
The other product is a Velvet Matt lip pencil in 060 In The Mood For Dragon Fruit. A cool-toned dark red. Creamy as always. Great pencil.